When is the best time to join a startup?

The question isn’t just “When is the best time to join?” but “When is the right time for you?”

Timing can make or break your experience with a startup.

Each stage of a startup brings unique risks and rewards. Understanding the dynamics at play — and assessing your own risk tolerance and career goals — is key to making a smart decision.

Here’s a look at the typical phases of a startup, the trade-offs they present, and how to navigate them.

Forwarded this email? Join 1,300+ founders and sign up!

TL;DR

🧡 P.S. Know someone ready to level up as a founder (or become one)? Share this newsletter and help their journey.

1. Idea stage (pre-seed)

At this point, it’s all vision and minimal structure. Founders are usually working out of coffee shops, with pitch decks instead of products. Most of the value lies in potential. If you join a startup here, expect ambiguity, long hours, and a lack of clear direction.

📈 Pros:

• High Equity Potential: Since the company has almost no funding or revenue, founders are more willing to share substantial equity.

• Major Influence: You’re shaping the product, culture, and early processes. Your work has immediate, visible impact.

📉 Cons:

• Extreme Risk: The majority of startups don’t make it past this stage. There’s no guarantee your equity will ever have financial value.

• Low or No Pay: Salaries are often minimal or nonexistent, so this stage is more about long-term gains than immediate financial rewards.

Best for: Those with high risk tolerance, a passion for building from scratch, and financial flexibility.

2. Product development stage (seed to early-growth)

Here, the product is being developed, tested, and refined. The company may have raised initial funding, allowing for some early hires and small salaries. There’s still significant risk, but now there’s a more concrete foundation.

📈 Pros:

• Growth Potential: If the startup is successful, you’re positioned to grow with the company and potentially take on a larger role.

• Equity: Though lower than in the idea stage, you still stand to gain significant equity.

📉 Cons:

• Moderate Risk: Many startups fail before they find a sustainable product-market fit. Your equity might still end up worth zero.

• Work-Life Balance: The hours remain intense, and there’s little stability in terms of job structure or long-term security.

Best for: Those who want the experience of scaling a product, have a reasonable risk appetite, and are motivated by equity potential over immediate stability.

3. Growth & scaling stage (series A - series C)

At this stage, the startup has validated its product, found product-market fit, and is focused on scaling. Funding is stronger, and the team is growing. The company is aiming for aggressive growth, which often brings operational challenges and the need for new talent.

📈 Pros:

• Better Compensation: Salaries and benefits improve, and equity is still an attractive incentive, though it may be diluted.

• Career Development: You have more structure, support, and resources, and potentially clearer growth paths within the company.

• Lower Risk: The startup is no longer just a risky concept; it has customers, revenue, and proof of its viability.

📉 Cons:

• Less Influence: The core product and direction are largely set, so there’s less room for shaping big-picture decisions.

• Higher Expectations: The pace and pressure remain intense, with a strong focus on scaling quickly and hitting ambitious targets.

Best for: Those seeking a balance between growth potential and stability, and who enjoy the challenges of scaling and optimizing processes.

4. Late stage (series D and later)

Late-stage startups are often more like mid-sized companies. They have a well-defined market, strong revenue, and may be preparing for IPO or acquisition. It’s no longer a “small team in a garage” vibe; now it’s about sustaining growth and preparing for major financial events.

📈 Pros:

• Competitive Pay: Salaries are competitive, sometimes including bonuses and other incentives.

• Equity with More Predictability: While equity offers are smaller, the likelihood of liquidity is higher if IPO or acquisition is near.

• Career Stability: There’s more structure, work-life balance, and established processes.

📉 Cons:

• Less Startup Spirit: The company may feel more corporate, with more layers of management and formalised processes.

• Limited Upside: The big equity gains are often behind you, and there’s less room for massive growth in terms of valuation.

Best for: Those looking for a safer bet with competitive pay and reasonable work-life balance, and who are less concerned with maximizing equity upside.

Five types of risk

When a startup is in its first stages, it is nothing but risk. Successfully building a company is the act of slowly decreasing (or ideally — eliminating) that risk until you have created a reliable cash flow machine.

There are (usually) five types of risk:

1. Technology risk - can we get the product to work?

2. Market risk - can we build something people love?

3. Scaling risk - can we acquire lots of customers?

4. Business model risk - can we serve customers profitably?

5. Defensibility risk - can we maintain market share?

Remove one of them, and the expected value of your business goes up massively.

Remove all of them, and a business will become one of the most successful in the world, worth billions of dollars. 

The main problem in startup nowadays? Not enough potential startup employees think about risk, even though it is the #1 thing that determines their economic outcome.

🧡 P.S. If you subscribe today — you will get the best approaches to dealing with each of the categories of the given risk in your inbox on Monday!

📩 Get a free pitch deck

Raising soon? I’ll send you over Passionfroot’s pitch deck that raised over $3M, just refer one friend via your personal referral link: https://foundersfuel.beehiiv.com/subscribe?ref=PLACEHOLDER

Additionally, I’ll add you to a private founder community where I post valuable resources daily.

✈️ How I Can Help

Get your news where Silicon Valley gets its news 📰

The best investors need the information that matters, fast.

That’s why a lot of them (including investors from a16z, Bessemer, Founders Fund, and Sequoia) trust this free newsletter.

It’s a five minute-read every morning, and it gives readers the information they need ASAP so they can spend less time scrolling and more time doing.

Subscribe for free

Seeking impartial news? Meet 1440.

Every day, 3.5 million readers turn to 1440 for their factual news. We sift through 100+ sources to bring you a complete summary of politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a brief 5-minute email. Enjoy an impartial news experience.

Join for free today!